Good or bad?

(I have my grandfather to thank for this - partly)

1: Oh, man, I just lost my job!

2: Oh, that's bad.

1: No, it's good, because I got an even better job.

2: Oh, that's good.

1: No, it's bad, because it meant I had a whole lot more responsibility.

2: Oh, that's bad.

1: No, it's good, because it meant I was tested as a person.

2: oh, that's good.

1: No, it's bad - I failed the test.